Website Strategy

Is Your Website Secretly Costing You Clients? Here's How to Find Out

One of the main questions I get on discovery calls is, "How the heck am I even supposed to know if my website is costing me sales?"

And the truth is, it's a great question. The tricky thing about a website that's costing you sales is that you would never know it's happening.

Nobody will ever send you a message saying "Hey, I was thinking about hiring you, but your website sucked so I didn’t"

They just wouldn’t reach out in the first place.

Which makes it hard to know whether investing in a website will actually bring value to your business- or whether it won’t.

The thing is that if your website is costing you clients, there are usually clues. Maybe your marketing isn't bringing in quality leads. Maybe you get pushback when you share the price. Or maybe even you internally cringe when someone asks for your website.

I want to make it clear that the goal of this post is NOT to sell you on why you need a website, on the contrary, it's to give you clarity on whether or not your website (or lack thereof) is costing you actual clients.

Because when you have clarity, you could make informed decisions about whether your website needs improvements, what those improvements might be, or whether your time and energy would be better spent somewhere else in your business.

In this post, I'm walking you through three steps to take an objective look at your website, evaluate how well it's doing its job, and identify whether it could be costing you clients.

Ready? Let's get into it.

Step 1: Understand What Your Website Is Actually Supposed to Do

Do you know why you need a website for your business?

Because most coaches and consultants don’t. They think it's to be able to be found online.

Which is important, but if people are finding you, but not buying, your website is not doing its job.

The purpose of your website is simple: To be the bridge that connects your marketing to your sales.

Let me explain, say you're a consultant. Grinding away at outreach, creating content, putting yourself out there, and working your butt off to show people the amazing work you can do. You are letting people know you exist with all of your marketing efforts.

Ideally, all that marketing should lead to discovery calls, where you talk with potential clients and show them how you can help.

The problem is that just because someone knows you exist doesn't mean they're ready to buy.

Before someone becomes a client, they might want to learn more: Who are you? What exactly do you do? Are you actually able to help them? Are your services actually worth what you're charging?

And that is where your website fits in the picture.

Your marketing gets you in front of potential clients. Your website convinces people that you're the person to hire. And your sales process turns that pre-sold buyer into paying clients.

Step 2: Figure Out Whether Your Website Is Where You're Losing Clients

Now that you understand your website's job, the next question is: Is your website actually the thing that's holding your business back?

In my experience, when a business is struggling to grow, there's usually a bottleneck in one of four places:

  • People don’t know you exist.
  • People know you exist, but aren't reaching out.
  • People are reaching out, but aren't buying.
  • People are buying, but you're struggling to charge what your work is worth.

If your bottleneck is that people don’t know you exist, even the best website in the world isn't going to do diddly squat because nobody will ever see it.

So the question I would ask you is: What's holding you back from letting people know you exist?

Is it that you don't know how to market your business? Or do you know what to do, but you're just not doing it?

Because if you don't know how to market your business, a new website isn't your highest priority. Figuring out how to attract potential clients is.

But if you know what to do and you're still not doing it, it's worth asking yourself why.

  • Is it because you don't feel confident putting yourself out there?
  • Or is it because you're worried all that effort won't actually turn into clients?

If you don't feel confident putting yourself out there, having a professional website you're proud to share can make marketing your business feel a whole lot easier.

And if you're worried your marketing efforts won't turn into clients, your website is supposed to help bridge the gap between your marketing and your sales.

Now, what about the other three bottlenecks?

  • People know you exist, but aren't reaching out.
  • People are reaching out, but aren't buying.
  • People are buying, but you're struggling to charge what your work is worth.

If people know you exist but aren't reaching out, your website might not be giving them enough information or confidence to take the next step.

If people are reaching out but aren't buying, your website might not be doing enough to build trust and communicate your value before they get on a sales call.

And if people are buying but you're constantly having to justify your prices, your website might not be communicating what makes your services worth the investment.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that any of this means your website is automatically costing you clients. Right now the goal is to simply identify where you're getting stuck before assuming your website needs fixing.

Once you have an idea of where the problem might be, you can take a closer look at whether your website is contributing to it.

Step 3: Is Your Website Costing You Clients?

At this point, we've figured out two things:

  1. That the purpose of your website is to be the bridge between your marketing and your sales
  2. And hopefully we also figured out where your business is currently losing clients

And while we've established that a bad website can cost you clients, that doesn’t mean that your website is actually costing you clients.

So let's take a closer look at your website to see if it is up to par.

In order for your website to take someone who knows you exist and turn them into a pre-sold client it needs to answer two questions.

  1. Is it clearly articulating why your ideal clients should choose you?
  2. Do they trust you to deliver on what you say you can do?

Because if people don't understand why they should choose you, or they don't believe you can do what you say you can do, they won’t hire you.

And if your website isn't doing a good job of answering those questions, there's a pretty good chance it's leaving potential clients with doubt instead of giving them the confidence they need to take the next step.

This is what I call Clarity and Credibility, two of the core foundations of my Authority Engine framework.

1. Clarity: Is It Obvious That You Are the Right Choice?

When someone lands on your website, they should be able to quickly understand who you help, what problem you solve, and why your offer is worth what you are charging.

We do this by clearly communicating the problems you solve, the results you help clients achieve, and how your services can help them get there.

So take a look at your website.

If someone who's never heard of you landed there today, would they immediately understand why they should choose you over someone else?

2. Credibility: Do People Believe You Can Help?

Now, just because someone understands what you offer doesn't mean they're automatically going to trust you enough to hire you.

After all, anyone can say they're great at what they do.

The question is, what are you doing to cement that trust with potential clients?

That's where things like testimonials, case studies, examples of your work, and even a professional website can come in.

They're all ways to show potential clients that you're the real deal.

So take another look at your website.

Are you giving people reasons to trust you? Is your credibility undeniable?

Or are you expecting them to take your word for it?

Stop Guessing Whether Your Website Is Costing You Clients

Instead of guessing whether your website is costing you clients, you now have a way to take a closer look at what's happening in your business and decide whether your website is something worth investing in.

And I think that's a really important question to ask.

Because I've seen firsthand how much business owners can miss out on when their online presence isn't doing its job.

In a sample survey of 12 of my clients, the average reported increase in revenue was $60,350.

And what I find so interesting is that many of them had no idea how much their website might have been holding them back.

Take my client Esty, for example: She decided to do something about her online presence after a potential client told her he didn't trust her enough to hire her.

After we worked together, her revenue grew by 77% in 90 days, and she started closing contracts on the same day.

Maybe your website is doing its job just fine. Or maybe it's creating doubts, leaving questions unanswered, or making it harder for people to see the value you bring.

Either way, it's worth finding out. And you don't have to figure it out alone.

That's exactly what my discovery calls are for.

We'll take a look at what's happening in your business, where you might be losing potential clients, and whether your website is something worth improving.

If you've been wondering whether your website is costing you clients, I'd love to help you get some clarity.

Book a discovery call here

Recent Posts

See All

Get recognized and paid like the expert you are

Your website is teaching people how seriously to take you, make sure you are showing up as the best possible version of yourself.

Book a Free Discovery Call